Schumann Konzertstück for 4 horns and orchestra – Bayerisches Staatsorchester, Nagano

Recommendation
Overview
Artists
Purchase
Recommendation

The big story about this new Farao Classics Super Audio CD is the astonishing level of technical and musical playing achieved by the Bayerisches Staatsorchester French horn section performing Robert Schumann notoriously difficult Konzertstück for Four Horns and Orchestra. Kent Nagano leads the orchestra in two other works, Wagner’s Siegfried-Idyll and the Metamorphosen for 23 Solo Strings by Richard Strauss, which sound splendid. But we have those works in other sublime performances already. This recording of the Konzertstück is the best that I have ever heard.

At the time that Schumann wrote his Konzertstück, the recently developed valve horn was offering undreamt of possibilities over the natural horn – possibilities which Schumann utilized without restraint, demanding chromatic melodic lines from all four of his solo players across the entire range of their instruments. The Konzerttstuck had been considered unplayable since its premiere in 1850 until a performance in Munich’s Odeon concert hall in 1887 that caused a sensation among critics. Still today, orchestras rarely program the work because it is so outrageously challenging. To hear it played at the level of perfection that it is here is an experience not to be missed by brass aficionados, and one which will be revelatory for the casual brass music listener.

Following two opening strokes by the full orchestra, the dauntless Munich hornists respond with a striking fanfare. It is a flourish that is arresting not because it is powerful, but that is powerful because it is perfect – balance, intonation, tonal beauty – in all ways. And so goes the performance; we are off to the races and can only sit back and be amazed.

Following is a You-Tube video of the Orquesta Sinfónica de Galicia horn section performing the opening of the Konzerttstuck.